Sony-Zee merger collapse exposes fault lines in M&A landscape

The Indian media landscape has been rocked by a dramatic turn of events. The highly anticipated $10-billion merger between Zee Entertainment Enterprises Ltd (ZEEL) and Sony Pictures Networks India, once poised to create a titan in the entertainment space, has spectacularly crumbled. With Sony walking away, citing alleged breaches by ZEE, a series of legal battles and uncertainties now cloud the future of both companies. What will be the aftermath of this unexpected unraveling, its implications for ZEE and Sony, and the broader media industry, particularly in the face of the looming Reliance-Disney juggernaut? As legal claws sharpen and financial calculations are re-drawn, a question hangs heavy in the air: who will emerge victorious from this shattered billion-dollar dream?

ZEE, having navigated challenges in recent years, now faces the prospect of legal battles. Sony India is pursuing a termination fee amounting to $90 million, accusing ZEE of breaches in the Master Cooperation Agreement (MCA). This has led to the invocation of arbitration and the initiation of interim relief proceedings against ZEE. In response, ZEE categorically denies all claims made by Sony, refuting any breach of the MCA and specifically contesting the demand for a termination fee.

Also read:

Sony terminates merger agreement with Zee

Merger termination: ZEE denies all assertions raised by Culver Max and BEPL

M&A deals, especially those involving behemoths are complex and challenging because of the scale, and complexities, opines Anupriya Acharya, South Asia CEO, Publicis Groupe.

Plus, she adds, the two parties need to agree on the objectives of the M&A activity, shared vision and the future of the merged entity, cultural and integration issues, etc. “Something that looks good on paper may not necessarily get concluded. As per media reports, Sony Group has formally notified Zee that it is calling off the merger; the fruition of which would have created a formidable entertainment giant. However, such developments are not unusual as far as M&A goes, because it takes many milestones to conclude such deals successfully,” she adds.

Karan Taurani, Senior Analyst at Elara Capital, feels that it is an unfavourable end game which could give birth to more legal battles.

Taurani adds that Sony has called off the merger alleging breaches by ZEE of the terms of Merger Cooperation Agreement (MCA), invoking arbitration and seeking interim reliefs against ZEE. ZEE has denied all the assertions raised by Sony on the alleged breaches under the terms of the MCA, including their claims for the termination fee. ZEE mentioned that the company took all steps in line with the MCA, approved by its shareholders and all regulatory authorities and has consistently worked towards the implementation of the mentioned scheme in the interest of the shareholders. ZEE also mentioned that it held several deliberations and good faith negotiations with Sony, with a view to consider an extension (six months) of the merger completion timeline, that did not materialise.

ZEE is evaluating all the available options and will take all the necessary steps to protect the long-term interests of all its stakeholders, including by taking appropriate legal action and contesting Sony India’s claims in the arbitration proceedings.

Taurani says that ZEE will continue to evaluate organic and inorganic opportunities for growth, leveraging the intrinsic value of its assets. “ZEE has clearly mentioned that Punit Goenka agreed to step down in the interest of the merger and proposals in this regard were discussed, including for appointment of a director on the Board of the merged company, in the best interest of ZEE’s directors and shareholders. Hence, the actual reason for Sony terminating the merger remains unknown,” he adds.

The aftermath

In the aftermath of Monday’s cancellation of the proposed $10 billion merger between the giants, several brokerages have opted to downgrade Zee Entertainment’s shares. The two companies are expected to face a slew of legal hurdles and disagreements as well.

With a termination of this deal, any legal recourse to fee claims from either side will be long and convoluted, notes N. Chandramouli, CEO, TRA Research. “The disagreement and termination is quite simple on the face of it, but clear underpinnings as a matter of trust erosion with Sony feeling uncomfortable with issues around Punit Goenka’s governance and regulatory compliance. We can say one thing for sure, that business dealings between the two will be severely impacted by the failure of this deal as well,” he adds.

ZEE and Sony both needed each other to survive in the competitive entertainment market, but due to the unfortunate termination of the merger, ZEE is clearly at a loss, says Rupesh Kashyap, brand culturist and creative director. “This is attributed to issues related to their financial crisis as well as challenges on the promoter's front. Assuming ZEE accepts the termination, one can hope for a drama-free resolution,” adds Kashyap.

Proposed Reliance-Disney merger

As the media industry witnesses this unexpected unraveling, questions arise about the impact of potential competition from the proposed merger of Reliance and Disney. How will ZEE navigate these challenges, especially considering the financial prowess and success models of emerging entertainment giants? With a track record of success, and an arsenal of top-tier talent, this alliance is set to reshape the dynamics of the industry. Could the potential competition from the Reliance-Disney merger impact ZEE’s future performance in the media industry?

According to Rupesh Kashyap, the proposed RIL-Disney merger has the potential to dwarf others, leveraging RIL’s giant presence in the telecom business. Platforms like Netflix, with their distinctive content and paying subscribers, will attract even more viewers in the coming days.

Reliance Jio’s collaboration with Disney+ Hotstar is set to establish India’s biggest entertainment business, backed by substantial financial resources, a proven success model, and a pool of talented individuals, as noted by N Chandramouli. He suggests that ZEE may struggle to sustain its position due to its ongoing financial constraints. He points out that Sony played the role of a saviour for ZEE during a near-insolvency crisis, a success story bordering on a business miracle.

Karan Taurani feels that the termination will likely have adverse effects on both parties involved. This is attributed to the fact that both companies are currently navigating intense competition in the digital media landscape and are potentially vulnerable to the looming threat posed by the Reliance-Disney merger in the short term. The termination of their collaboration appears to exacerbate the challenges they face in this competitive and evolving market.

As the media industry witnesses this unexpected turn of events, the termination of the ZEE-Sony merger serves as a reminder of the intricacies and uncertainties inherent in large-scale business transactions, leaving stakeholders and industry observers pondering the potential implications on the competitive dynamics of the entertainment sector.